Moon Knight Clarifications

🕸️TV Tropes
Status - Trees🌳🌲
⚡Mem-Clozed

Asylum Storyline of Moon Knight

The storyline of the asylum in Moon Knight is one of the most confusing and pivotal parts of the series. Here is a breakdown of what's happening, explained in points:

The "Asylum" Is Not a Real Asylum

It's the Duat: The "asylum" is a manifestation of the Egyptian afterlife, specifically the Duat, which is the underworld.

Because Marc Spector has dissociative identity disorder (DID), his psyche projects the environment as a psychiatric hospital, with Arthur Harrow as the head psychiatrist.

A Purgatorial Journey: Marc and Steven's "stay" in this asylum is a journey through the Duat after they were killed by Arthur Harrow.

Their "therapist," the hallucinated Dr. Harrow, is trying to get them to confront their past and balance their scales.

The staff and other patients are also people they've encountered in their life, adding to the psychological nature of the setting.

What Is Actually Happening: The Afterlife Explained

They Are Dead: Marc and Steven were shot and killed by Arthur Harrow. Their consciousness is now on a boat sailing through the Duat.

Taweret, the Guide: The hippo headed goddess, Taweret, is the real guide of their soul. She appears as a friendly, maternal figure. Her job is to guide souls through the Duat to the next stage of the afterlife.

The Scales of Justice: Taweret explains that to pass into the Field of Reeds (the Egyptian version of paradise), their heart must be weighed on the Scales of Justice against the Feather of Ma'at (truth and justice). The scales must be perfectly balanced.

Confronting Their Past: Marc and Steven learn their scales are unbalanced. Taweret tells them they must confront their past and open up to each other to balance their hearts. This leads to the painful revelations of Marc's childhood trauma.

Marc's Trauma: The "asylum" scenes where they go through the memories are Marc's repressed memories. This is the real part of the story. We learn that Marc created Steven's personality as a child to cope with the physical and emotional abuse he suffered from his mother after his younger brother's accidental death. Marc blames himself for his brother's drowning, and his mother blames him as well.

The Origin of DID: This is the crucial moment where the show explains that Marc's DID is a direct result of this childhood trauma. Steven was created as a way for Marc to escape and have an innocent, safe place in his mind.

The True Afterlife: Duat vs. Field of Reeds

The Duat (the underworld): This is the treacherous, purgatorial realm where souls face their past. The boat, the hostile spirits, and the desert landscape (a reflection of the Duat) are the real afterlife.

The Field of Reeds (paradise): This is the true "heaven" in Egyptian mythology. Souls who pass the "Weighing of the Heart" ceremony get to live in this lush, beautiful paradise for eternity.

The Tragic Climax and Resolution

The Sacrifice: Despite a moment of reconciliation, Marc and Steven's scales remain unbalanced. As the Duat's hostile spirits try to pull them from the boat, Steven, in a heroic act of self sacrifice, falls into the sands of the Duat to save Marc.

The Scales Balance: With Steven gone, Marc's heart is now "whole," and the scales instantly balance.

Reaching Paradise: Marc finds himself in the Field of Reeds, a beautiful and peaceful paradise.

The Choice: Marc refuses this paradise, choosing to go back for Steven, symbolizing his acceptance of both his own identity and Steven's importance to him. He returns to the Duat to save Steven, and in doing so, they are both reborn.

In short, the asylum is a psychological manifestation of their journey through the Duat, the actual Egyptian underworld. The events within the asylum that reveal Marc's past are the true backstory, while the "Dr. Harrow" persona is a psychological trick. The real afterlife is the journey through the Duat, and the ultimate destination is the Field of Reeds. The most important part of this entire sequence is the emotional journey for Marc and Steven, as they finally understand and accept one another.

The third guy in Moon Knight

You've hit on the biggest mystery and most important reveal in the entire Moon Knight series: the third personality.

That "third guy" is Jake Lockley.

Here's what's going on with him:

He's the Most Brutal Alter: In the comics and the show, Jake Lockley is a cab driver and a much more violent, ruthless personality than either Marc Spector or Steven Grant. He's the alter that is willing to do things the others won't, including killing without hesitation.This is why Khonshu has an arrangement with him.

The Blackouts: Throughout the series, there are several moments where both Marc and Steven "black out" and wake up to a scene of carnage, with no memory of what happened.

They are often surrounded by dead or brutally injured people. This is Jake taking over. For example, in the third episode when Marc is interrogating the thugs, he blacks out and wakes up on a cliffside with the thugs dead and a bloody knife in his hand. Neither Marc nor Steven knows how it happened—it was Jake.

He Was There All Along: The show subtly hints at his presence from the very beginning. Remember the third sarcophagus in the asylum? It was rattling and shaking. That was Jake, locked away from Marc and Steven's consciousness. When they finally accept each other and are in the afterlife, Jake's part of their mind is still contained, so he isn't part of their journey to balance the scales.

The Final Act: At the end of the series, after Marc and Steven defeat Harrow, they refuse to kill him, despite Khonshu's urging. They tell Khonshu they are done with him and demand to be released from his service, which he reluctantly does. However, in the post-credits scene, we see a seemingly defeated and drugged-up Harrow being wheeled out of a psychiatric hospital.

The man pushing the wheelchair is Jake Lockley, who speaks fluent Spanish. He puts Harrow in a white limousine with Khonshu, who reveals that while he may be done with Marc and Steven, he's not done with their body because he still has a deal with Jake.

Khonshu says, "Why would I ever need anybody else when he has no idea how troubled he truly is?"

Jake then shoots and kills Harrow, effectively finishing the job and proving his ruthless nature.

The Actor's Name is Oscar Isaac. Really great actor.